A major American museum gives keys to using art in teaching all kinds of subjects.
Receive our File of the week by email
Stay informed about digital learning in all its forms. Great ideas and resources. Take advantage, it's free!
Articles
The phenomenon of influence is taking on incredible proportions. Influencers created with AI manage to have millions of followers on Instagram in the image of magazineluiza or Lil Miquela. Others, real ones like soccer players or rappers, accumulate tens or even hundreds of millions.
The problem is clear: a voice amplified by likes is not synonymous with truth. This apparent credibility, often disconnected from accuracy, confuses students, who prefer charisma to rigor.
Behind every publication lie a variety of interests: sponsors, financial gain, or ideological agendas. Take the example of disguised promotions: an influencer may praise a beauty product without mentioning that she is paid by the brand. Virtual influencers, controlled by companies, or paid real influencers will play on their image to sell any product.
Influencers use well-known techniques: partial facts mixed with exaggerations, biased storytelling or the omission of key elements.
In a world where influencers shape minds with captivating narratives, often for the benefit of masked interests, teachers need to equip students with practical tools and skills to distinguish truth from falsehood. These skills - rigorous investigation, detection of emotional bias and analysis of intentions - form a shield against manipulation, accessible from an early age thanks to appropriate and engaging methods.
To free pupils from the grip of influencers promoting gadgets, cosmetics or slimming products, initiating a playful investigative approach is an effective first weapon. Karl Popper(The Logic of Scientific Discovery, 1934) teaches us that truth requires active doubt rather than passive acceptance. This principle can be transformed into an educational game. Take a TikTok video in which a celebrity presents a "miracle detox" drink.
Influencers excel at manipulating through emotions, exploiting levers such as fear or joy to captivate their audience. Jonah Berger, in his book Contagious, points out that emotional content captures attention more effectively, a mechanism to be demystified as early as the first years of high school. Imagine an Instagram story playing on ecological guilt to promote a "green" app.
Understanding who's behind a message and what it omits is a key step in unmasking manipulation. Influencers, whether human or virtual, often serve commercial interests masked by seductive narratives. What's needed is a systematic analysis of evidence and gaps. Let's take a post promoting an "anti-stress" bracelet.
Teachers encourage students to reason for themselves rather than follow blindly. An effective exercise is to present them with an influencer's publication - for example, an Instagram story about a health trend - and ask them to solve the problem: is it reliable? They would seek out studies, compare opinions, and draw their own conclusions. This cognitive autonomy prepares them to be more than just passive consumers of information.
Classroom debate is a powerful lever for sharpening critical thinking skills. By discussing a topic influenced by networks, such as climate change relayed by influencers, students confront their points of view. One student may defend a viral video, another challenge it with scientific data. This process, inspired by Paul and Elder's recommendations on critical thinking, forges a nuanced collective mind, capable of weighing up the pros and cons without giving in to social pressure.
Teachers are role models: by demonstrating intellectual rigor - for example, by verifying a source live in front of the class: they embody the quest for truth. The Council of Europe advocates integrating media education into curricula to promote responsible digital citizenship.
By raising awareness of bias and fake news from a very early age, educators can train citizens to navigate in an ecosystem where the truth is often masked or altered by hidden interests.
Influencers complicate access to the truth by mixing facts and biased narratives, but skills like source verification and critical thinking, combined with proactive education, can redress the balance.
By transforming the classroom into a space where the quest for truth becomes a collective adventure, educators prepare students to face a world of ambiguous information. In this age of influence, schools must not only protect, they must enlighten.
See more articles by this author
Publish at February 26 2025 Updated February 26 2025
Truth in the age of influencers: discerning the true from the false
Navigating fake news and reality: educational keys to unmasking influence
More and more social network users blindly believe or are susceptible to content shared by influencers without checking the reliability of the information. In classrooms, students cite TikTok or Instagram as sources as often as textbooks. TikTok's search engine is gradually replacing Google among young people.
But is separating the real from the fake so complicated when influencers dominate social networks? We ask how education can equip young people to deal with this phenomenon. We begin by exploring the ambiguous role of influencers as truth filters, followed by essential skills for thwarting manipulation and educational strategies for cultivating cognitive autonomy and transparency.
Influencers as truth filters: a blurred landscape
For young people, influencers have become essential references. Yet on TikTok, their authority is based on popularity rather than verifiable expertise on the subjects they discuss.
Perceived authority, not always deserved
The phenomenon of influence is taking on incredible proportions. Influencers created with AI manage to have millions of followers on Instagram in the image of magazineluiza or Lil Miquela. Others, real ones like soccer players or rappers, accumulate tens or even hundreds of millions.
The problem is clear: a voice amplified by likes is not synonymous with truth. This apparent credibility, often disconnected from accuracy, confuses students, who prefer charisma to rigor.
The motivations behind the stories
Behind every publication lie a variety of interests: sponsors, financial gain, or ideological agendas. Take the example of disguised promotions: an influencer may praise a beauty product without mentioning that she is paid by the brand. Virtual influencers, controlled by companies, or paid real influencers will play on their image to sell any product.
The subtle mix of real and fake
Influencers use well-known techniques: partial facts mixed with exaggerations, biased storytelling or the omission of key elements.
For example, a viral video about a miracle diet may cite a real study, but omit its limitations to seduce the audience. This mix blurs the line between reality and fiction, making young people particularly susceptible to confusing narrative with fact.
Acquiring the skills to spot manipulation
In a world where influencers shape minds with captivating narratives, often for the benefit of masked interests, teachers need to equip students with practical tools and skills to distinguish truth from falsehood. These skills - rigorous investigation, detection of emotional bias and analysis of intentions - form a shield against manipulation, accessible from an early age thanks to appropriate and engaging methods.
Investigating like detectives: dissecting the origin of messages
To free pupils from the grip of influencers promoting gadgets, cosmetics or slimming products, initiating a playful investigative approach is an effective first weapon. Karl Popper(The Logic of Scientific Discovery, 1934) teaches us that truth requires active doubt rather than passive acceptance. This principle can be transformed into an educational game. Take a TikTok video in which a celebrity presents a "miracle detox" drink.
- Activity: "Hunting for clues" - Primary school pupils create an "identity card" of the author: who is he (name, face drawn) and where did he say it (platform, date)?
The teacher can ask a simple question: "Is this an advert in disguise?" by showing an example such as a can discreetly branded.
- Concrete solution: Use a classroom poster with illustrated steps - "Author?", "Context?", "True or not?" - which students follow in teams to compare the video with a simplified article (e.g., a post on hidden sugars).
This approach teaches youngsters to track down the origin of messages and spot clues to commercial intent, all while having fun.
Avoiding emotional traps: recognizing psychological levers
Influencers excel at manipulating through emotions, exploiting levers such as fear or joy to captivate their audience. Jonah Berger, in his book Contagious, points out that emotional content captures attention more effectively, a mechanism to be demystified as early as the first years of high school. Imagine an Instagram story playing on ecological guilt to promote a "green" app.
- Activity: "Decoding feelings" - Students note what they feel (fear of doing the wrong thing? desire to act?) then identify what triggers this state: dramatic music, shock images. The teacher asks: "Is it an emotion or a fact?"
- Concrete solution: Show two videos - one with emotional effects, one neutral from an expert - and guide a discussion: "Which seems truer and why?" A grid with "Music", "Images", "Strong words" helps to list artifices.
This method sensitizes students to strategies that divert their reason, preparing them not to give in to impulsive feelings.
Scrutinizing hidden agendas: assessing the reliability of evidence
Understanding who's behind a message and what it omits is a key step in unmasking manipulation. Influencers, whether human or virtual, often serve commercial interests masked by seductive narratives. What's needed is a systematic analysis of evidence and gaps. Let's take a post promoting an "anti-stress" bracelet.
- Activity: "The court of evidence" - Schoolchildren play judge and lawyer: one group defends the bracelet (influencer's arguments), another challenges it (search for scientific evidence). The teacher provides a counter-example: studies biased by brands to minimize risks.
- Concrete solution: Create a "truth checklist" - "Who gains something?", "Solid evidence?", "What's missing?" - which students apply to real publications, with supervised access to reliable resources (e.g. educational sites).
This process reveals intentions and forges vigilance against deliberate omissions.
The role of education: cultivating autonomy and transparency
Encouraging cognitive autonomy
Teachers encourage students to reason for themselves rather than follow blindly. An effective exercise is to present them with an influencer's publication - for example, an Instagram story about a health trend - and ask them to solve the problem: is it reliable? They would seek out studies, compare opinions, and draw their own conclusions. This cognitive autonomy prepares them to be more than just passive consumers of information.
Encouraging debate and confrontation of ideas
Classroom debate is a powerful lever for sharpening critical thinking skills. By discussing a topic influenced by networks, such as climate change relayed by influencers, students confront their points of view. One student may defend a viral video, another challenge it with scientific data. This process, inspired by Paul and Elder's recommendations on critical thinking, forges a nuanced collective mind, capable of weighing up the pros and cons without giving in to social pressure.
Promoting transparency in a digital world
Teachers are role models: by demonstrating intellectual rigor - for example, by verifying a source live in front of the class: they embody the quest for truth. The Council of Europe advocates integrating media education into curricula to promote responsible digital citizenship.
By raising awareness of bias and fake news from a very early age, educators can train citizens to navigate in an ecosystem where the truth is often masked or altered by hidden interests.
A collective adventure
Influencers complicate access to the truth by mixing facts and biased narratives, but skills like source verification and critical thinking, combined with proactive education, can redress the balance.
By transforming the classroom into a space where the quest for truth becomes a collective adventure, educators prepare students to face a world of ambiguous information. In this age of influence, schools must not only protect, they must enlighten.
You might also like:
Experimenting with risk to adapt
It's sometimes difficult to understand children who don't dare to do very much. However, it's not usually their fault: they're victims of overprotection by adults, who don't give them the keys they need to analyze their environment or adopt appropriate strategies. Shouldn't we let them grow up and experiment on their own? When societal overprotection undermines the ability to adapt.
The disciplines of sensitivity are just as important to the formation of a human being as the disciplines of knowledge. Dare to articulate the two.
Adapting Teaching to Working Memory
Memory is one of the most important skills in a learning process. All the more so as two parts are stimulated. The so-called working memory receives the information and must make sense of it so that it can be stored more permanently in the long-term memory. Of course, it is possible to try to improve one's working memory but an adjustment of the teaching or revision framework would be more appropriate.
Learning kanji from two ignorant masters
Established systems are not always the most effective. By experimenting and observing, it is possible to find more suitable forms of intelligence to serve the most varied wills.
