Articles

Publish at March 15 2016 Updated July 21 2026

Formative Assessment vs. Summative Assessment: The Golden Age of Differentiation

No Differentiation Without Continuous Assessment

In an educational system such as France’s, assessment takes on particular importance because it underpins both the design of instruction and the determination of whether a student is ready to advance to the next grade.

Indeed, while the National Education Ministry’s overall policy aims to extend differentiated instruction to all students, benchmarks are still set to ensure a minimum standard: these are summative assessments.

However, this assessment of knowledge is increasingly shifting toward continuous, progressive, and regular evaluation, rather than a final exam reserved for graduation years, such as the DNB (National Brevet Diploma) or the baccalaureate. It thus evolves into formative assessment, capable of identifying not only what students have learned but also their weaknesses, which allows teachers to adapt their lessons accordingly and move toward differentiated instruction by combining pedagogy, teaching, and interpersonal skills.

Toward Automated Differentiation

In France and Canada, education authorities quickly recognized the benefits of this approach. By proceeding in this way and basing their instruction on formative assessment, it becomes more natural—even automatic—for teachers to implement differentiated instruction. This approach aims to adapt the delivery of knowledge to each student’s specific needs.

Once intended primarily for students with disabilities, it now extends to all vulnerable groups (those living in poverty, migrants, students with disabilities, learning disabilities, illnesses, etc.) and can even be beneficially applied to any student, regardless of background. Today, teachers aim to help each student reach their full potential in terms of openness and understanding, despite the diversity that this may entail within a single classroom.

Toward a More Equitable Education

In France, the process was set in motion by the 2005 Equal Opportunity Act. Since then, there have been numerous approaches to achieving this goal, which are frequently discussed at conferences or through the sharing of best practices andexperiences aimed at finding methods and tools so that all learners—from the weakest to the strongest— can learn to learn better and more ambitiously—including gifted and high-potential students.

The tools are varied and are limited only by the creativity and ingenuity of teachers.

The current middle school reform in France officially highlights differentiated instruction as its cornerstone, notably through an increase in personalized support and group work, even though its implementation remains highly complex.

Illustration: racorn - ShutterStock

References

Diagram illustrating the main aspects of differentiated instruction
(PDF) - Educational Resources Department, CS des Affluents
http://differenciation.org/pdf/Schema_aspects_differenciation_pedagogique.pdf

Instructional Differentiation
How to Do It? - Évelyne Touchard - Grenoble School District
http://www.ac-grenoble.fr/ien.g4/IMG/pdf/Diaporama_Atelier_Formation_differenciation_pedagogique.pdf

Differentiated Instruction (.pdf) - Lille School District
http://www4.ac-lille.fr/~ienlens/file/AED/La_differentiation_pedagogique.pdf

What Is Differentiated Instruction? - Differentiated Instruction (Collaboration Among Teachers Across Different Grade Levels)
http://differenciationpedagogique.com/questceque/questceque

Instructional Differentiation in Response to
challenges encountered in the classroom - Fabienne Neiss - Expérithèque - French Ministry of Education
http://eduscol.education.fr/experitheque/fiches/fiche12146.pdf

Video Clips to Support Differentiated Instruction - Educavox
http://www.educavox.fr/formation/pratiques/des-capsules-video-au-service-de-la-differenciation-pedagogique

Assessment in Schools - Eduscol
http://eduscol.education.fr/pid23504/evaluation-a-l-ecole.html

Assessing Learning - Formative Assessment - CERI Report
http://www.education.gouv.fr/archives/2012/refondonslecole/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/rapport_ocde_ceri_evaluer_l_apprentissage_l_evaluation_formative_2008.pdf

Middle School 2016: Everything You Need to Know About the Reform - Ministry of National Education
http://www.education.gouv.fr/pid32484/college-2016-tout-savoir-sur-reforme.html


See more articles by this author

Files

  • Ongoing evaluation

Thot Cursus RSS
Need a RSS reader ? : FeedBin, Feedly, NewsBlur


Don't want to see ads? Subscribe!

Superprof: the platform to find the best private tutors  in the United States.

 

Receive our File of the week by email

Stay informed about digital learning in all its forms. Great ideas and resources. Take advantage, it's free!